Ashurst Perkins Coie Governance & Compliance Update – Issue 89
Institutional Shareholder Services has published its 2026 UK 'Proxy Season' Review. The full review is available for download from ISS-Corporate’s resources page.
Key takeaways include:
These findings are mirrored by those of Georgeson, which notes a decrease in shareholder opposition to remuneration reports and policies respectively, albeit with policies attracting more dissent than remuneration report resolutions for the first time. Their research also finds, in a surprise to very few, that UK institutional investors are more likely to vote against remuneration-related proposals than their US counterparts.
ISS Stoxx Governance has undertaken its 2027 benchmark voting policy consultation, seeking views on proposed changes to its UK and global policies.
For its UK benchmark policies, ISS sought views on whether to reflect the evolving governance landscape for smaller companies in the UK and/or listed on the London Stock Exchange including changes to:
For its global benchmark policies – i.e. those which apply to all jurisdictions - ISS sought views on:
ISS expects to announce the final changes to its 2027 benchmark policies in late November 2026. They will be applied to shareholder meetings held on or after 1 February 2027.
You can review the changes ISS made to its voting guidelines in 2025 in our publication: 2025 AGM and reporting season; what to expect.
Glass Lewis has published its 2027 UK Proxy Voting Policy, setting out broad investor opinion on various topics ahead of the 2027 AGM season. Glass Lewis confirms in the 2027 guidelines that, in light of its announced intention to move away from publishing a single 'house policy' towards, instead, producing multiple perspectives 'representing the varied viewpoints of its clients', and having considered relevant regulatory and corporate governance developments, it has concluded that its policies do not require revision for 2027. This policy shift is not expected to impact on voting recommendations during the 2027 AGM season.
In reaching its decision not to revise the UK proxy voting guidelines for 2027, Glass Lewis considered the following regulatory changes:
You can review the changes Glass Lewis made to its voting guidelines in 2025 in our publication: 2025 AGM and reporting season; what to expect.
The Financial Reporting Council has published its Annual Review of Corporate Governance Reporting. It analyses how a sample of 100 companies reported against the 2024 iteration of the UK Corporate Governance Code (2024 Code), highlighting examples of good practice and identifying areas for improvement. This is the first review of reporting against the 2024 Code. For ease of reference, our overview of the FRC's 2025 review can be found at APCGC Update, Issue 74 – Item 1. The review follows the FRC's Annual Review of Corporate Reporting 2025/26, published in September 2026 (see APCGC Update, Issue 87 – Item 4).
The FRC notes that the 2024 Code places greater emphasis on two things: reporting the outcomes of board decisions, and the quality of explanations for departures. It finds that outcomes-based reporting is developing but is not yet consistently insightful. Better disclosures connect a board decision or action to what changed and why it mattered. Too often, however, reports describe what the board reviewed or discussed, or simply label information as an 'outcome' without explaining the resulting impact. The strongest outcomes-based reporting was on shareholder engagement and board performance reviews.
The FRC also looked at whether annual reports could be made more concise. Almost half of the reports reviewed contained duplication, repetition or both, irrespective of company size. Companies are encouraged to:
All that said, the FRC accepts that legislative and regulatory requirements may dictate where some information must appear. For example, principal risks must be reported in the strategic report.
The FRC is encouraged that its review contradicts the perception that the Code is 'comply or else'. 39 companies reported at least one departure from a Code provision, compared with 25 in 2025 and 28 in 2024. This is broadly in line with the longer-term pattern of around one third of companies reporting a departure. Nearly all companies clearly identified the provisions concerned, which the FRC consider to be progress on previous years, although the FRC believes that the quality of explanations still needs to improve.
The most common departures were:
The FRC restates the elements of a good explanation set out in its guidance: context and background, a convincing rationale, mitigating actions, consideration of risks, and when the company intends to comply. It invites all companies to read that guidance.
Key FRC messages in specific areas of corporate reporting include:
Revised Provision 2 requires the board to assess and monitor culture and how the desired culture has been embedded. While 83 companies referred to embedding culture, only 48 reported how the board assesses and monitors this. The FRC believe that separating implementation from oversight will assist in demonstrating how a board maintains accountability for cultural outcomes.
It was noted that disclosures often focused on individual cultural attributes, such as safety or continuous feedback, rather than the desired culture as a whole. The FRC also cautions against citing workforce survey results without linking them to board activity or giving prior-year comparisons.
When reporting on monitoring culture, several companies reported on workforce survey results as evidence that the desired culture had been embedded without explaining how those results could be linked to company efforts or monitoring by the board. Without comparative figures from the previous year, the FRC's view is that it is difficult to assess progress.
'Outcomes' means the effects of board decisions: what changed and why it mattered. The FRC suggests asking 'So what changed because of the board's actions?'. Phrases such as 'the board reviewed' are a start but not enough, and vague outcomes such as 'valuable insights' tell readers little. Better reporting would describe what the insights were, what the board did with them, and what changed as a result.
Good outcomes-focused reporting was observed in relation to board performance reviews. Many companies explained the actions they had taken in response to the previous year's review and, importantly, described the impact of those actions.
Reporting on outcomes of workforce engagement and cyber oversight was weaker. For example, several companies described town hall meetings at which issues could be raised, yet few disclosed what the issues were or if the board had taken any action in response. Others stated that cybersecurity remained a priority without offering further detail.
Companies should also ensure that outcomes are related to the engagement undertaken and reporting teams should interrogate whether narrative labelled as 'outcomes' are, in fact, outcomes at all.
Almost all companies reported engagement outside the AGM, but many reports remained generic. Good reporting referred to the number of engagements, the methods used, issues and topics raised by shareholders. The FRC has repeated its encouragement for companies to provide a summary of engagement activities undertaken by the board, including objectives, a summary of issues, participants, progress of dialogue, and the outcome of the engagement.
Better outcomes-focused reporting was found when engagement concerned remuneration. Several companies explained how they consulted on remuneration policies and how this engagement had influenced the proposals subsequently put to their AGM.
The number of companies describing chair engagement rose from 59 to 64, Remuneration Committee Chair engagement from 35 to 53, and SID engagement from 12 to 15.
The FRC was less enamoured of statements that chairs were 'available to meet' shareholders without confirming whether any engagement took place. Better reporting would identify the relevant board members participating in engagements, the views expressed, and how these were communicated to the wider board.
26 companies received votes of 20% or more against the board's recommendation on at least one resolution, and most reported some form of response.
98 companies referred to a board diversity policy, 87 included insight into the policy or a link to where it is available on its website and 61 reported clear diversity and inclusion objectives. Objectives varied from those who had adopted the UK listing Rules targets (stemming from the FTSE Women Leaders and Parker Reviews) to those who had implemented targets connected to the nature of the company.
The strongest reporting explained how objectives were implemented, the progress made and how diversity supported strategy or a company's wider success.
This is the first year the Standard has been incorporated into the Code (through Provision 25). All FTSE 100 and FTSE 250 companies in the sample referred to it.
Many limited their disclosure to a statement of compliance; the FRC would like more company-specific explanation of how the Standard has been embedded.
Good disclosure in relation to auditor independence explained the wider safeguards and processes used to protect auditor independence and objectivity beyond the implementation of a non-audit services policy.
Audit Committees may also wish to consider how to factor into assessments of quality their auditor's use of technology, including agentic and generative AI.
Disclosure of AQR inspections with key findings has fallen. Inspections graded 'improvements required' were disclosed appropriately only 5% of the time (2025: 20%), and none graded 'significant improvements required' were disclosed (2025: 30%). 'Significant improvement' is needed here.
On CRR engagement, 15 of the 16 sample companies written to disclosed the correspondence. Providing transparent disclosure of CRR interactions, together with how findings have been incorporated, considered and applied, helps investors assess the quality of companies' reporting and their commitment to continuous improvement.
The average number of principal risks was 10. Better reporting clearly explains how the board has determined which risks are principal risks and demonstrates how these relate to the company's specific circumstances. The strongest disclosures provided insight into the board's assessment processes, including how principal risks have been evaluated against the company's risk appetite and strategic objectives. They also explained how those risks are monitored and mitigated through the broader risk management and internal control framework.
97 companies included cybersecurity in their principal risks. 98 discussed board or committee involvement in cyber risk, including their role in responding to actual incidents, and 83 mentioned the cyber expertise available to the board, including regard for the government's Cyber Governance Code of Practice. 90% of companies discussed the work undertaken to promote a cyber-resilient culture.
Companies mentioning AI rose from 86 to 95, and 68 considered AI within their risk frameworks. However, 10 companies discussed their operational use of AI without discussing its governance and risk management. Better risk reporting recognised both the risks and opportunities of AI, as well as the need for careful governance.
Nine companies said they used AI in reporting, up from one in 2025. This was generally deployed for sustainability reporting or analysis of staff surveys.
Revised Provision 29 applies to periods beginning on or after 1 January 2026. Boards must declare whether material controls were effective at the balance sheet date and explain how they reached that conclusion. Reports should explain how the board reached its conclusion, including the processes, evidence and assurance sources considered.
92 of the 100 companies reported some form of preparation, with better reporting covering not only the technical work undertaken but also the role played by the board and its committees in overseeing and challenging that work. The strongest disclosures explain how boards have engaged with management, internal audit and others to identify material controls, assess effectiveness, review progress against implementation plans and monitor readiness for the new reporting requirements. The FRC believe that such readiness activities are likely to form the foundation of future Provision 29 disclosures and provide examples of good disclosure.
The FRC believes that companies will now need to move from describing preparations to clear, company-specific reporting that supports the declaration. Where weaknesses exist, the FRC expects an explanation of:
This is the first assessment against the strengthened malus and clawback provisions (amended Provision 37 and new Provision 38). Companies must now explain why their chosen malus and clawback period is appropriate and whether the provisions were used; reporting on this varied considerably. Only one company reported activating malus or clawback during the period.
On NED remuneration, two companies were considering policy changes following the FRC's November 2025 guidance clarification on paying NED fees in shares. None referred to share options for NEDs.
For the first time, the review includes a section on small caps. They showed a slightly higher incidence of Code departures, mainly from Provisions 9 (Chair independence) and 19 (Chair tenure). They also showed that high-quality reporting need not be lengthy or complex.
Eight of the 20 small caps had adopted the Provision 21 three-year external board performance review cycle.
Further information
The FRC will hold a webinar to discuss the review's findings, followed by a live Q&A – date will be released in due course.
As a consequence of the Non-Financial Reporting Review, the government has published the draft Companies and Partnerships (Strategic Report Exemptions etc.) (Amendment and Consequential Amendments) Regulations 2027. For a reminder of the government's overarching Regulation Action Plan, see APCGC update, Issue 72 – Item 2.
In summary, the draft regulations exempt certain medium-sized companies and wholly-owned subsidiaries from the requirement to produce a strategic report. Specifically, the draft regulations augment section 414 of the Companies Act 2006 and amend other sections to create exemptions from the duty to produce a strategic report for:
Companies excluded from being treated as medium-sized under section 467 include, among others, public companies and companies carrying on a regulated activity or insurance market activity.
By way of reminder, the thresholds for determining the size of a company for reporting purposes were raised in 2025. For a reminder of those elevated thresholds, see APCGC update, Issue 60 – Item 7.
Subsidiaries excluded from this exemption include those which are also traded companies (i.e. those with securities admitted to trading on a UK regulated market, such as the main market of the London Stock Exchange), banking companies, authorised insurance companies, companies carrying on insurance market activity and companies with securities admitted to trading on AIM.
Companies taking advantage of this exemption must include a statement to that effect in a prominent position on their balance sheet as well as including the parent undertaking's name and registered number and a statement that its parent undertaking has prepared a group strategic report in which the company is included for a financial year of the parent that either ends at the same time as the financial year to which the subsidiary's balance sheet relates, or is the financial year ending last before the end of the financial year to which the subsidiary's balance sheet relates.
The draft regulations will come into force on the fifth day after the day on which they are made. We will issue a short update confirming if and when that happens.
The Small Business Regulatory Taskforce's report has been published by the Department for Business, Innovation, Science and Trade and HM Treasury, alongside the government's response.
The Taskforce made 15 recommendations, with the government accepting all of them except one: the proposed exemption from the confirmation statement for dormant companies.
By way of background, the Taskforce was a joint government–industry group. It ran from June to September 2026 to support the government's target of cutting the administrative cost of regulation by 25%. The report groups its 15 recommendations into five areas: regulatory submissions, guidance, passporting, SME capability and enforcement. The main theme is 'tell government once': i.e. that a business should not have to give the government the same information more than once. The two biggest causes of burden SMEs reported were working out what they need to do to comply, and record-keeping.
The government's response can be summarised as follows:
Next steps
Several measures depend on Spending Review decisions or on the Regulating for Growth Bill receiving Royal Assent. We will, of course, update you on relevant developments as the recommendations are implemented.
The European Securities and Markets Authority (ESMA) has published its final report containing revised guidelines on delaying the disclosure of inside information under the EU Market Abuse Regulation (EU MAR).
The revisions align the guidelines with the changes to the EU MAR disclosure regime introduced by the EU Listing Act (see AGC Update, Issue 84 - Item 9).
Background
Under EU MAR, as with the UK Market Abuse Regulation (UK MAR), an issuer must disclose inside information that directly concerns it to the public as soon as possible. In certain circumstances, an issuer may delay public disclosure to avoid prejudicing its legitimate interests, provided the conditions for delay are met. The guidelines provide non-exhaustive examples of situations in which an issuer may have a legitimate interest in delaying disclosure.
ESMA consulted on draft revised guidelines in February 2026 (see AGC Update, Issue 79 - Item 8).
What has changed?
ESMA has identified five additional legitimate interests that may justify delayed disclosure. These include situations where the issuer: (i) has been requested by a public authority not to disclose the information; (ii) needs to collect additional information about an exceptional event or circumstance, such as the effects of a cyber incident; or (iii) risks losing business opportunities as a result of disclosing sensitive commercial information.
ESMA has also removed the examples of legitimate interests relating to protracted processes. This reflects the fact that, further to the EU Listing Act, issuers are no longer required to disclose inside information relating to intermediate steps in a protracted process - only the final circumstances or event must be disclosed, as soon as possible after it has occurred.
In addition, ESMA has removed the existing guideline addressing situations in which delayed disclosure is likely to mislead the public. This follows from the EU Listing Act amendments, which replaced that condition with a new requirement that the inside information which an issuer seeks to delay the disclosure of must not be in contrast with the issuer's latest public announcement or other communication on the same matter.
When will the guidelines apply and to whom?
The revised guidelines will apply from the date of their publication on ESMA's website.
Note that the revised guidelines do not apply to issuers that are subject only to UK MAR – i.e. have securities admitted to trading on UK public markets. However, UK issuers with financial instruments admitted to trading on an EU trading venue remain subject to EU MAR in respect of those instruments and should take the revised guidelines into account.
The Financial Conduct Authority has published Primary Market Bulletin 67 which covers proposals to modernise the publication of markets regulatory information, a review of the use of AI by sponsors, changes to user profile updates in the Electronic Submission System or 'ESS' and a consultation on changes to the FCA's Knowledge Base following amendments to the UKLR and PRM sourcebooks.
Two issues to highlight in this publication are:
New interface for the NSM and further changes
By way of reminder, the National Storage Mechanism is the FCA's public archive for market disclosures. The enhanced interface is designed to help investors, issuers and other market participants access the information they need more efficiently. The new NSM functionality is described in a user guide.
The enhanced NSM is the first milestone in a wider programme to modernise the publication of regulatory information. Over time, the FCA intends to bring together datasets to provide one authoritative place for users to find, access and reuse information in a location to be known as the ‘FCA Markets Information Resource & Archive’ or 'FCA MIRA'. This will include:
Changes to the Knowledge Base
The FCA is also consulting on amendments to its Knowledge Base. This includes the revocation of its technical note: TN 103.1 – The independent business requirements for companies applying for premium listing, which sets out guidance on the independent business requirement under former Listing Rule 6, which has since been replaced by UKLR 5.2 and 5.3. Given that the requirements of LR6 were not carried forward into the UKLR, the FCA's view is that TN 103.1 is no longer relevant.
The consultation closes on 9 December 2026.
The Financial Reporting Council has published its UK Stewardship Code 2026 Review of Reporting. This is the first review of reporting under the 2026 iteration of the Code.
The review found that signatories have used the flexibility of the 2026 Code to produce more streamlined and reader-friendly reports.
The UK government has announced its intention to introduce a mandatory human rights due diligence regime (mHRDD) across the UK for services, and additionally in Great Britain for goods. The largest UK and overseas businesses will have a legal duty to identify, assess and address human rights risks in their operations and supply chains. For more detail, and thoughts on what businesses can do to prepare, you can review our update here.
The intention is the new requirements will come in to force by December 2027, to coincide with the application of the Forced Labour Regulation in the EU and Northern Ireland.
On 11 November 2026, the UK government published a consultation on its proposed approach to introduce a regime to regulate illegally produced 'forest risk commodities' (FRC) and to strengthen the existing UK timber regulations, which prohibit placing illegally harvested timber and timber products on the market in Great Britain (GB).
The FRC regime, which would implement the existing framework in Schedule 17 of the Environment Act 2021, aims to reduce the link between products used by businesses in GB and illegal deforestation carried out to clear land for growing or rearing FRC.
The consultation does not contain draft regulations although these are expected in 2027 and the government aims for scheme to be in force in 2028.
The consultation follows an earlier 2022 consultation and aims to align the proposed GB regime with the EU Deforestation Regulation (EUDR), which will now apply from the end of December 2026 including in Northern Ireland (see EU Deforestation Regulation: preparing for compliance).
It is proposed that the existing timber regulations that apply in GB will be retained but strengthened, rather than bringing timber into the new FRC scheme (as is the case under the EUDR).
Both the GB and EU schemes will target the same list of commodities: coffee, cattle, cocoa, oil palm, rubber and soy. Unlike the EUDR, the GB scheme is not proposed to target commodities produced on deforested land if that was not illegal in the country of origin. It will also only apply to businesses with over £1 million in global annual turnover in the previous financial year. Another key difference is that there will not be a requirement under the GB regime to make any advance notification that due diligence has been completed before products can be imported for use.
Although final policy on the FRC regime is subject to consultation, the direction is clear and closely tracks the EUDR. Businesses already preparing for the EUDR should be well placed for compliance with the GB regime but should assess any differences between EU and GB requirements once draft legislation is available.
The International Sustainability Standards Board (ISSB) has published a consultation on an Exposure Draft of its practice statement on nature-related disclosures. It has also published Accompanying Guidance and its Basis for Conclusions as well as a snapshot summarising the Exposure Draft and an FAQs document.
Publication of the Exposure Draft follows the ISSB's May 2026 confirmation that it would publish an IFRS Practice Statement covering nature-related disclosures rather than produce a standalone nature standard or amend its existing sustainability disclosure standards (see AGC Update, Issue 82 – Item 7).
The Exposure Draft builds on the existing requirements in IFRS S1 (sustainability disclosures) and S2 (climate disclosures) to specify how companies can provide decision-useful disclosures on sustainability-related risks and opportunities (SROs) relating to nature and it is intended to be applied when reporting under S1 and S2. The Exposure Draft does not change any of the existing requirements in S1 and S2. The Exposure Draft also builds on the Taskforce for Nature-related Financial Disclosure (TNFD) framework, recommendations, metrics and guidance.
The Exposure Draft helps reporting entities understand:
The Exposure Draft proposes additional nature-related disclosures on: (i) how a company is responding or plans to respond to NROs; (ii) the resilience of its strategy and business model to uncertainties arising from nature-related risks informed by a nature-related scenario analysis; (iii) the amount and percentage of assets or business activities vulnerable to nature-related risks and those aligned with nature-related opportunities, (iv) metrics associated with the disclosure topics in the SASB Standards (and in the EU sustainability reporting standards (ESRS) or the TNFD if desired); (v) any nature-related targets the company has set; and (vi) a statement on compliance with the practice statement where all of its requirements are met.
The Exposure Draft proposes proportionality mechanisms and transitional reliefs aligned with those in IFRS S2.
The consultation closes on 19 February 2027. Feedback is sought on both the form and content of the Exposure Draft. The ISSB also intends to publish information mapping the TNFD's recommendations with the requirements of the Exposure Draft.
On 12 November 2026, the EU Commission published a call for evidence on a standard setting common procedures for statutory auditors and independent assurance service providers when assessing companies' sustainability reporting. A related consultation on the technical advice on the standard received by the Commission in September 2026 is running in parallel to the call for evidence.
The call for evidence outlines two options for developing the assurance standard:
The assurance standard is required as entities in-scope of the Corporate Sustainability Directive (CSRD) have to obtain limited assurance of their sustainability reporting based on a standard adopted under the Audit Directive (2006/43/EU).
The call for evidence closes on 18 January 2027. The Commission aims to adopt the standard in Q2 2027 to meet the deadline for adoption that was extended by the Omnibus I package to 1 July 2027.
If you would like to receive future Ashurst Perkins Coie Governance & Compliance updates, please click here to sign up.
Authors: Will Chalk, Partner; Shan Shori, Expertise Counsel; Becky Clissmann, Sustainability Counsel; Marianna Kennedy, Senior Associate, Tom Cummins, Senior Counsel.
The information provided is not intended to be a comprehensive review of all developments in the law and practice, or to cover all aspects of those referred to.
Readers should take legal advice before applying it to specific issues or transactions.