Data centre dash: managing disputes risks in Australia
Australia's data centre sector is booming. Driven by exponential growth in artificial intelligence workloads, cloud computing, and increasing digital sovereignty expectations, the race to build new capacity has intensified. Operators, developers, investors and their advisers face tight timeframes where speed to market is critical. But that urgency creates significant disputes risk.
Data centres need heavy capital spending, complex technology and long-lead supply chains. They depend on water, energy and connectivity. And they operate under fast-moving, unpredictable regulation. The result is a fertile ground for disputes impacting the entire project lifecycle: from development and construction risk, to performance problems, ESG issues, customer contract termination risk and investor disputes where the data centre is not delivered on time. To date, parties have brought fewer formal disputes than you might expect. They have needed to deliver and move on to the next project, and they value their commercial relationships. But history shows these disputes will escalate into formal proceedings once the dust settles, conditions tighten or the issues become too significant to ignore.
The United States offers a timely illustration of how quickly these pressures can crystallise into formal disputes. There, community concern about power, water, noise and the cost of supporting infrastructure has moved rapidly from the planning table to the courtroom: local opposition blocked or delayed at least 75 projects worth around US$130 billion in the first quarter of 2026 alone, and in Virginia the proposed Prince William Digital Gateway, planned as one of the world's largest data centre campuses, was abandoned after the courts voided its rezoning approvals for failure to comply with public notice requirements. Opponents are increasingly pairing procedural challenges to local approvals with environmental claims, such as the recent federal Clean Air Act proceedings over the gas-fired power plants supplying data centre campuses in San Antonio, Texas, while New York State has imposed a statewide, yearlong moratorium on new hyperscale facilities. We expect Australia to follow a similar trajectory as its pipeline grows, making early community engagement and rigorous, well-documented approvals processes more important than ever.
Supply chain risk. Highly specialised and heavily supply-constrained equipment (such as cooling and power equipment, electronics, GPUs, chips, and battery storage) is generally procured internationally, exposing it to the risk of tariffs, export and trade controls or logistical factors increasing the cost of equipment or delaying its delivery to site. Disputes can arise over liability for project delays or additional costs.
Technology obsolescence. Data centres must accommodate rapid advances in technology and are vulnerable to obsolescence. Disputes over defective design or fitness-for-purpose obligations can arise when there is a mismatch between legacy designs (such as cooling systems) and evolving compute density. Intellectual property disputes can arise over technology supplied or developed.
Water and cooling constraints. Data centres require advanced cooling systems to cope with the increased thermal load of high-density AI workloads. Cooling choices may face community and stakeholder opposition (eg if using potable water) which may lead to environmental litigation and approvals challenges. Droughts and other climate-related conditions only add to the challenge.
Contracting and delivery. Access to skilled, available contractors is difficult and highly competitive. The necessity for multiple contractors increases interface risk, and disputes risks relating to quality. Joint ventures may become strategically misaligned or face challenges raising capital.
Access to (the right type of) power. Reliable power is fundamental to data centres, with many hyperscale customers requiring near perfect uptime of 99.99% or 99.999%. Any disruption to power supply can trigger significant service credits or termination rights, so disputes tend to arise where operators seek to claim force majeure to avoid these dire consequences. In addition, developers of data centres may need to comply with ESG requirements for power to come from renewable sources.
Regulatory change and localisation requirements. As the data centre sector expands rapidly, governments are facing pressure to manage perceived risks through regulation of, for example, data, cybersecurity, sustainability and siting. We are already seeing governments at the federal and State levels proposing changes in law to regulate the perceived risk of data centre development and manage impacts on communities. Some of these requirements are overlapping and will create a complex regulatory compliance environment for data centres. This may lead to disputes over change in law provisions or possible investor-state treaty claims where steps taken effectively expropriate a foreign investor's investment.
Statements about ESG credentials. Whether as a result of legal obligations or community expectations, the construction and operation of many data centres will be accompanied by public statements about sustainability such as energy or water usage, or other ESG-aligned credentials. These statements will be subject to regulator and private scrutiny and potential allegations of greenwashing in a similar manner to some climate-related disclosures in recent years.
Layered on top of all of this is uncertainty as to the ultimate commercial necessity for all of the data centre capacity being built, particularly to support AI. Any downturn in the market will accentuate many of the factors underlying disputes.
Well-structured projects and contracts can materially reduce disputes risks when building new data centres. It is critical to manage risk across your entire contract suite, including interface risk between your construction contractors and suppliers, by ensuring the commitments are allocated and passed down appropriately.
Important points to consider at the outset include:
Community engagement and social licence. Incorporate community investment and transparent communications about energy and water use and other ESG matters into project plans. Early engagement reduces planning risk and the likelihood of injunctive relief, administrative challenges, or environmental claims including in the form of class actions. Determine preferred approval pathways early and allow sufficient time for approvals processes, as understaffed agencies, a flood of applications and growing community concern lead to more delays.
Supply chain resilience. Diversify suppliers and qualify alternates in advance. Build milestone payment structures and liquidated damages provisions into sub-contracts to pass down the risk of delay. Consider intellectual property risk allocation and fallback mechanisms to ensure supply is not disrupted by an intellectual property dispute. Ensure IP escrow accounts are fit for purpose and monitored during the project. This requires specialist advice.
Change-in-law provisions. Include robust change-in-law mechanisms to address the real risk of regulatory change.
Schedule and price changes. Balance fixed-price and schedule certainty with mechanisms to adapt to changes in the market or unexpected delay. Include carefully drafted force majeure, price adjustment, and variation clauses to help reduce the scope for disputes over entitlement to additional cost and extensions of time.
Extension of time provisions. Ensure due consideration is given to the provisions required within construction contracts including that extension of time provisions are well thought out and deal with the risk profile agreed (including for weather issues), and that appropriate concurrent delay and notice provisions are adopted.
Contractual caps and carve-outs. Carefully consider limitation clauses including appropriate fault-based carve-outs to ensure that these clauses do not disincentivise performance.
Termination rights. Include mechanisms to terminate the contract if expectations are not met and specify the compensation payable on termination.
Dispute resolution provision. Incorporate a dispute resolution provision that is fit for purpose and consistent across the entire contract suite. It may be prudent to incorporate expedited dispute resolution processes such as a standing dispute adjudication board for fast technical determinations as part of a tiered dispute resolution clause. Arbitration is a popular choice for resolving disputes between international parties because it can provide a neutral forum apart from local court systems; is private; and arbitration awards are more readily enforceable internationally under the New York Convention than court judgments under reciprocal enforcement regimes. Where expert determination or arbitration is chosen, consistency across the contract suite is critical to facilitate the consolidation of disputes or joinder of parties, where appropriate, and necessary to avoid the risk of inconsistent findings across multiple forums and inefficiencies associated with running multiple separate proceedings.
Enforcement planning. Think about enforcement up front by mapping out where your counterparty has assets against which you might enforce an arbitral award. Incorporate alternative forms of security in the contract including parent company guarantees or performance bonds that are payable on demand.
Investment treaties. For international investors, think up front about international investment treaty protection and structure new investments to attract protection.
Security of payment. Be mindful of the security of payment regime applicable to the State where the data centre is being constructed when drafting your contracts. For example, ensure the provisions in your construction contracts do not condition the right to payment in a way that purports to displace the operation of the relevant security of payment legislation. Recent case law indicates this may constitute impermissible contracting out.
Proportionate Liability regimes. Consider whether or not you wish to contract out of proportionate liability legislation, and if so ensure you have selected a state that expressly permits this. Ensure that any provisions dealing with joint and several liability are consistent with this choice.
Effective contract administration and document creation and retention. During the project, keep an eye on rights that were carefully negotiated and ensure they are not waived. Although a commercial resolution to disputes is to be preferred, if rights have not been preserved you will be negotiating from a weaker position and if documents are not preserved you will not be able to prove your claim. Ensuring adequate resources and support is key.
The explosion of activity in the data centre sector in Australia offers enormous opportunity, but the pace and scale of development means disputes risks are real and growing.
To date, disputes in this industry have generally led to re-baselining of the project rather than a formal dispute resolution process due to the importance of delivering projects on time to maximise economic returns. But as the industry matures and there is greater focus on incremental project costs, formal disputes are likely to become more common.
A proactive, well-advised approach to risk identification and management can make the difference between a project that delivers on time and on budget, and one that becomes mired in costly disputes.
Authors: James Clarke, Partner and James MacDonald, Counsel.
The information provided is not intended to be a comprehensive review of all developments in the law and practice, or to cover all aspects of those referred to.
Readers should take legal advice before applying it to specific issues or transactions.