Legal development

CIPA reform enacted: SB 690 signals an end to private pen register claims

    Relief is on the horizon for businesses large and small that have been bombarded with dubious pen register or trap-and-trace device (pen/trap) lawsuits. On August 30, 2026, the California legislature passed Senate Bill 690, which Governor Gavin Newsom signed on September 30. The newly enacted law will go into effect on January 1, 2027, and eliminates the private right of action for any claims arising under California Penal Code § 638.51 based on “conduct occurring on an internet website, online application, or mobile application.” It applies to cases filed after January 1, 2025. While it will not end the deluge of wiretapping lawsuits the plaintiffs’ bar has brought over the past few years alleging violations of the California Invasion of Privacy Act (CIPA) against websites, mobile applications, and the analytics and advertising technology behind them, it will end most pen/trap claims, which have been especially difficult to defend.

    California enacted the CIPA in 1967 to regulate wiretapping and eavesdropping on confidential communications. While primarily a criminal statute, CIPA also includes a civil private right of action with a statutory damages provision (§ 637.2) that has provoked waves of litigation since the early 2000s, first as to companies’ call-recording practices and then as to various internet technologies. Several years ago, the plaintiffs’ bar began repurposing the statute to argue that routine website technologies (e.g., analytics tags, pixels, session-replay tools, and chatbots) amount to wiretapping or eavesdropping under §§ 631 and 632 or function like pen/traps under Penal Code § 638.51. Many thousands of such cases have been filed in that time, and more than 1,000 such cases are active at the time of this publication (in addition to countless more cases threatened by plaintiffs in demand letters) or currently being arbitrated—a huge number of those include pen/trap claims eliminated by the passage of SB 690.

    As initially introduced last year, the original SB 690 would have essentially eliminated civil liability under CIPA for online and mobile conduct covered by the California Consumer Privacy Act (CCPA), including both the wiretapping and eavesdropping claims (§§ 631 and 632) and pen register and trap and trace claims (§§ 638.50 and 638.51). Although that bill passed unanimously in the Senate, it was held as a two-year bill in the Assembly and ultimately amended to focus narrowly on pen register and trap and trace claims. In August, both houses unanimously passed the amended version, and Governor Newsom signed the bill on September 30, 2026, noting in his signing memorandum that "additional work is needed, as CIPA contains other decades-old statutes that are also susceptible to abuse by overly aggressive litigants. I urge the Legislature to take this on next year.”

    The new law expressly eliminates the private right of action, retroactively, for pending CIPA § 638.51 claims filed after January 1, 2025. As a practical matter, this means that not only can such claims not be included in future private lawsuits, but defendants should evaluate whether they can move to dismiss any pen/trap claims filed after January 1, 2025, on the grounds that SB 690 moots them. However, because many such lawsuits include multiple causes of action, SB 690 may not resolve an entire case, and plaintiffs may seek to replead their pen/trap claims under other theories (particularly wiretapping). In addition, it’s important to keep in mind that the law did not change the lawfulness of any particular conduct; it merely changed who can enforce such claims. The California attorney general retains sole authority to enforce § 638.51 claims concerning “conduct occurring on an internet website, online application, or mobile application.”

    While eliminating the private right of action for pen register and trap and trace claims may not result in the end of CIPA claims, it should provide some meaningful relief. Although most CIPA suits related to website technologies involve both the wiretapping and eavesdropping claims (§§ 631 and 632) and pen register and trap and trace claims (§§ 638.50 and 638.51), the §§ 638.50 and 638.51 claims have historically been more difficult to dismiss at the pleadings stage. Unlike wiretapping or eavesdropping claims that require the collection of the contents of a communication, plaintiffs were often able to defeat motions to dismiss pen/trap claims by arguing that merely collecting routine metadata concerning users’ web browsing—including the transmission of an IP address to a third party—satisfied the elements of a claim.

    Governor Newsom’s signing message for the bill encouraging the legislature to go even further to reverse the trend of CIPA litigation suggests at least his support for a broader bill next session that might address the wiretapping and eavesdropping sections of CIPA.


    The information provided is not intended to be a comprehensive review of all developments in the law and practice, or to cover all aspects of those referred to.
    Readers should take legal advice before applying it to specific issues or transactions.