Funds Insider: Competitive auction sales: winning on deal deliverability
Competitive auctions are increasingly won on deal certainty rather than pricing alone. We outline some of the ways that a bidder can demonstrate deal deliverability to get ahead of other bidders.
In recent years, we have seen competitive auctions become increasingly focused on certainty of execution. Where bidders are relatively close on pricing, a seller will often favour the bidder that offers the clearest and most reliable path to completion. This is particularly true for sponsor sellers that need to return capital to their investors.
We outline some of the main issues which bidders should consider when preparing a competitive bid.
Sellers will expect a bid to be backed by committed funding. For sponsors, this means providing an equity commitment letter from the fund, supported by evidence of sufficient, available, uncalled commitments.
Where a bid relies on acquisition financing, bidders should also aim to have fully negotiated "certain funds" financing documents in place. Rather than presenting a term sheet agreed with a lender, bidders should provide signed commitment papers with the full-form finance documents attached, and any outstanding matters should be within the buyer's control. The standard approach in the UK and Europe is now for the sale agreement to contain no financing condition.
Every condition in a sale agreement represents risk in deliverability. The most competitive bids restrict conditions to those required by law, typically mandatory and non-suspensory regulatory approvals, and avoid conditions relating to financing, due diligence, third-party consents or the absence of a material adverse change (a "MAC" clause).
Bidders should be pragmatic about which conditions they require and be prepared to take on risks that can be managed in other ways, for example through price mechanics, post-closing obligations or insurance.
Merger control and foreign direct investment conditions are now among the most significant sources of execution risk and delay.
Bidders should therefore undertake their filing analysis early, identify all mandatory and advisable filings, and be ready to explain in their bid which approvals are required and the expected timetable. Where regulatory risk is a real concern for the seller, bidders may consider offering contractual comfort, such as commitments to accept certain remedies (with appropriate ring-fencing as to who those commitments bind) or a longer long-stop date.
The seller’s advisers will compare bidders’ markups of the auction draft sale agreement closely, and a heavily amended draft, especially where the amendments alter the commercial terms, undo an attractive price. Bidders should focus their comments on points of genuine importance and try to accommodate the seller’s position (especially where changes would alter form over substance). Compliance with the requirements of the bid letter (e.g. full form mark-ups of transaction documents) is also advisable.
Sponsor sellers will generally seek a clean exit with minimal residual liability. Warranty and indemnity (W&I) insurance allows a bidder to obtain meaningful warranty protection while accepting a nominal cap on seller liability. However, there is the cost of the insurance premium for bidders to factor in.
Bidders should engage with brokers early, ideally building on any buy-side policy soft stapled to the process, so that the policy can be bound at signing. Being able to confirm that underwriting is complete, and that the bidder is comfortable with any anticipated exclusions, removes a potential point of negotiation and delay. Parties are increasingly looking to post-signing affirmative cover to reduce the underwriting period in competitive auctions.
Economic conditions and expanded regulatory landscapes have led to an increase in the time many bidders take to complete legal and financial due diligence. Bidders should resource their due diligence to complete within the process timetable, and indicate that any such remaining diligence is confirmatory only and limited to specific identified matters. A well-run auction process should mean vendor due diligence has been prepared to fully wrap the offered business warranty package (for the purpose of W&I insurance), such that top-up diligence can be limited and confirmatory.
It is also helpful to confirm that internal approvals, including investment committee sign-off, have already been obtained or will be obtained within a specified period, and that the bidder’s transaction structure, including any acquisition vehicles and tax structuring, is ready to go. A credible, short timetable to signing can be a decisive differentiator where bids are otherwise comparable.
Relationships built before a process launches can be decisive. Bidders who have engaged with the sponsor, the seller’s financial adviser and management in advance are better placed to move quickly and to be regarded as a credible counterparty.
Management terms and preference for a particular bidder can also sway the outcome of an auction. Where management will remain invested, and particularly where they have influence over the seller’s choice of buyer, a compelling package can set a bid apart even where prices are closely matched. Bidders should consider offering attractive incentive terms, for example a meaningful sweet equity pool, favourable leaver provisions and a flexible approach to rollover.
In a competitive auction, a strong price is only the starting point. Bidders who can demonstrate committed financing, limited to no conditionality and a clean, well-prepared offer will put themselves in the best position to be selected as the preferred bidder.
Authors: George Weavil, Partner; Ian Keefe, Partner; Jade MacDonald, Senior Associate; and Lottie White, Senior Associate.
The information provided is not intended to be a comprehensive review of all developments in the law and practice, or to cover all aspects of those referred to.
Readers should take legal advice before applying it to specific issues or transactions.