Legal development

23/5 Trading in the U.S. – Impact on Structured Product Offering Documents 

Insight Hero Image

    Introduction

    During the next few months, the NYSE Arca, Nasdaq and several other U.S. stock markets will open up for trading stocks during the late evening hours. These extended trading times raise a variety of considerations in the drafting of structured product offering documents and for a variety of market practices. These changes may raise interpretative questions under the terms of offerings that were drafted well before these changes were planned.

    The changes to the U.S. trading day may impact not only offerings in the U.S., but structured product offerings that take place entirely outside the U.S. The impact will also not be limited to specific "wrappers" – instead, structured notes, CDs, certificates and warrants can all be affected. All of these types of documents have terms that relate to the U.S. trading markets.

    In this article, we discuss these implications, and how some market participants may address them. In addition, as the market eventually moves towards full 24/7 trading, these points may need to be considered again.

    23/5 Trading on Nasdaq/NYSE – Summary of Timetable

    NYSE Arca and Nasdaq both plan to start trading U.S. equities 23 hours each day, on five days a week. This trading is scheduled to commence on Sunday, December 6, 2026.

    For each of these exchanges, the trading week will begin Sunday at 9:00 p.m.1 and will extend, other than for scheduled pauses, to Friday at 8:00 p.m. Each weekday will have:

    • a daytime trading period from 4:00 a.m. to 8:00 p.m.;
    • a one-hour trading pause2 from 8:00 p.m. to 9:00 p.m.; and
    • an overnight session from 9:00 p.m. to 4:00 a.m.

    Identifying the Trading Sessions

    For the avoidance of doubt, these two exchanges will divide up the trading day as follows:

    NYSE Arca

    • Early Trading Session: from 4:00 a.m. to 9:30 a.m.
    • Core Trading Session: from 9:30 a.m. to 4:00 p.m.
    • Late Trading Session: from 4:00 p.m. to 8:00 p.m.
    • Overnight Session (this is the new session): from 9:00 p.m. to 4:00 a.m., Sunday through Thursday evenings.

    Nasdaq

    • Day Session: from 4:00 a.m. to 8:00 p.m.
      • This session combines Nasdaq's current pre-market trading (4:00 a.m. –9:30 a.m.), regular market hours (9:30 a.m.–4:00 p.m.) and post-market hours (4:00 p.m. –8:00 p.m.).
    • Night Session (this is the new session): from 9:00 p.m. to 4:00 a.m., commencing on Sunday evenings, and ending on Thursday evenings.

    Nasdaq has indicated that its plans retain its core U.S. trading session, including the "opening cross" and the "closing cross", which support price discovery and benchmark pricing. Similarly, NYSE Arca will report an official closing price for its securities as of 4.00 p.m.

    Specific Terms of Structured Products Impacted by 23/5 Trading

    The changes to the trading periods can impact structured products because these instruments have contractual terms, described in their disclosure documents, that relate to the timing of a trading day. Depending how these provisions are drafted, the change in the trading day may have consequences that the issuer or a holder of the instrument would not have expected.

    Trading Day. For example, in "plain English," one would expect a "trading day" to be a date between Monday and Friday, which is not a holiday, and on which the relevant exchange conducts trading. In contrast, under the new trading schedule, there will be market trading on Sunday evenings. A trading day definition that simply refers to a day on which the relevant market may be open for trading, without modification, may have the unexpected result that a Sunday could be understood to be a trading day. Taken this way, a late Sunday evening price could end up being the date on which a market value must be measured under the terms of the notes. This result would be inconsistent with the expectations of market participants; accordingly, a proper definition of "trading day" for an individual stock would probably benefit from additional wording that clarifies that the term is referring to regular trading sessions that occur on weekdays.

    Closing Price. NYSE Arca and Nasdaq will continue to release a "closing price" that is measured at approximately 4:00 p.m. on weekdays. Most contractual definitions of this term will continue to work as expected, without modifications. This result is important, because the values that are used to determine the payments on the relevant structured products need to fall on the weekdays and at the times that issuers and holders would expect.

    Market Disruption Events. Market participants generally expect that there will be lower trading volumes during late night trading sessions, potentially resulting in wider swings in stock market prices. However, under the rules of NYSE Arca and Nasdaq, fluctuations of this type will not trigger an official halt, as would occur during the core trading session. Many definitions that are currently in use of "market disruption events" already are designed to only cover events that occur during the core trading session; we would expect this practice to continue in new documents after trading hours are extended.

    Typical contractual definitions of "market disruption events" include temporary closings of the relevant market. The scheduled one-hour closing of NYSE Arca and Nasdaq for maintenance should not be inadvertently trigger a market disruption event under these provisions. Similarly, if the trading of a stock during the overnight trading session that is discontinued as a result of exchange rules in order to facilitate a corporate action such as a merger or a stock split, that type of cessation of trading should not trigger a market disruption event.

    Barrier Events. Many structured notes have an "American style barrier" with continuous monitoring, meaning that the a "barrier event" can occur, potentially subjecting investors to a loss of principal, if the trading price of a stock falls below a specified level at any time during the trading day. Here too, limited trading in the overnight session may increase the likelihood of a stock price decreasing below the barrier. Some issuers may wish to limit the relevant monitoring to the regular trading session, in order to ensure that any barrier event is triggered under more typical market circumstances. If overnight trading hours are considered part of the monitoring periods, the calculation agent for the relevant structured product will need to have procedures in place to monitor those trades.

    No 23/5 Trading of Listed Structured Notes

    The new 23/5 trading framework applies to equity securities and ETFs. However, it does not apply to bonds, such as exchange traded notes and other listed structured notes. On the one hand, this may be a positive aspect of the rules for the structured products market, because it may be difficult to value listed structured notes during the evening trading sessions – for example, although stock prices may move, the index levels that govern the payouts on many structured notes will not be determined until the following trading day. On the other hand, changes in the value of the relevant stocks may occur that could impact the value of the relevant listed notes, but investors would have no ability to act with respect to these notes until the open of the main session on the following trading day.

    Additional Disclosure Issues

    Issuers and underwriters may wish to consider a variety of changes to their offering documents, to the extent that the existing disclosures are not viewed as broad enough to address these points.

    Risk Factors. Issuers may wish to disclose that changes in trading values that occur during the evening session may impact the value of their notes, even if trading in the relevant structured product is limited during that period. Due to limited trading activity, relevant stocks could trade in a more volatile manner during the overnight session.

    If a barrier event could be triggered during the overnight trading session, that may be appropriate to clearly indicate in the risk factor section. Decreased liquidity in the overnight trading hours may render a barrier event more likely during that period.

    In addition, the issuer of the structured product and its affiliates may engage in hedging activities during evening hours, which could impact value of the underlying assets and the related structured note, even though structured notes may not trade during the evening.

    Impact on Indices

    The changes to the U.S. trading hours are not expected to materially impact the methodologies used for the equity indices that track the U.S. market, such as the S&P 500 and the Nasdaq 100 Index. This is because these indices are reported only during the daily portion of market trading, and report a "closing level" at the end of that trading period.

    Looking Ahead

    Increasing trading activity around the clock in currencies, crypto assets, and now many stocks, reflects an increasing desire among many investors to have the convenience of round the clock trading. Will these developments impact structured products, resulting in a desire among investors to have their brokers effect transactions for them beyond current typical trading hours? Brokers may also need to reflect when and how they update their bid and ask prices to reflect after hours trading.

    As prices change overnight, issuers and affiliates will have greater ability to adjust their hedge positions relating to their structured products, potentially reducing the overnight gap risk. That being said, bid-ask spreads for trades in these securities may widen in the evening due to their lower liquidity. Market participants may need to consider these additional costs when pricing trades.

    Equity Derivatives Definitions

    Of course, structured note disclosures and contractual terms are significantly tied to the ISDA Equity Derivatives definitions. To the extent that ISDA updates its provisions at any time to reflect the technicalities of the expanded trading day, structured note market participants will likely to update their documentation accordingly.

    Conclusion

    Market participants should begin to assess their structured note documentation to ensure that there are no unexpected results as a result of the new trading activity. We anticipate that most documents will continue to emphasize that the relevant conditions that impact structured notes – valuation calculations, trading days, market disruption events, will continue to be defined by reference to the principal daytime portion of the trading day.

    Authors: Lloyd Harmetz, Partner; Mike Logie, Partner; Julia Lu, Partner and Nick Allen, Partner.


    1. All time references in this article are to New York City time, unless otherwise indicated.
    2. These pauses are intended to promote operational resilience and for clearing, settlement and reference-data processing.

    The information provided is not intended to be a comprehensive review of all developments in the law and practice, or to cover all aspects of those referred to.
    Readers should take legal advice before applying it to specific issues or transactions.